The problem: 1. The conference divisions have always been unbalanced. The east was the strongest for a while. But lately the west is now the strongest.
2. Conference realignment causes problems. Some longtime rivalries would be in jeopardy with realignment.
3. The two best teams don't always play in the conference championship game.
The solution: Dissolve the divisions. Continue to play in an eight game conference schedule. Each team plays three permanent opponents, which will include their most important historic rivals. The remaining five conference games of the year will be rotated within a four-year/home-home span between the remaining 10 conference teams.
Methodology: First, Identify the Historic or geographically important rivalries that need to remain played every year.
Alabama: Auburn (in-state rival. Iron Bowl)
Tennessee (border state. Third Saturday in October)
Arkansas: Missouri (bordering states)
LSU (border rival, Golden Boot trophy)
Auburn: Alabama (in-state rival. Iron Bowl)
Georgia (oldest series in the south)
Florida: Georgia (cocktail party)
Georgia: Auburn (oldest series in the south)
Florida (cocktail party)
South Carolina (border state)
Kentucky: Tennessee or Vanderbilt (border state)
LSU: Arkansas (border rival, Golden Boot trophy)
Texas A&M (border state)
Ole Miss: Miss State (in-state rival. Egg Bowl)
Miss State: Ole Miss (in-state rival. Egg Bowl)
Missouri: Arkansas (border state)
South Carolina: Georgia (border state)
Tennessee: Alabama (border state. Third Saturday in October)
Vanderbilt (in-state rival)
Texas A&M: LSU (border state)
Vanderbilt: Tennessee (in-state rival)
Second, fill in teams that make the most traditional, geographic and/or competitive sense. The three permanent opponents for each team would be as followed...
Alabama: Auburn
Tennessee
Mississippi (border state)
Arkansas: LSU
Missouri
South Carolina (entered the SEC together)
Auburn: Alabama
Georgia
Miss State (border State)
Florida: Georgia
Kentucky (both from SEC east)
Tennessee (both from SEC east)
Kentucky: Florida (both from SEC east)
Missouri (border state)
Vanderbilt (border state)
LSU: Arkansas
Texas A&M
Ole Miss (border state)
Ole Miss: Miss State
Alabama (border state)
LSU (border state)
Miss State: Ole Miss
Auburn (border state)
Texas A&M (geographic proximity)
Missouri: Arkansas
Kentucky (border state)
Texas A&M (entered the SEC together)
South Carolina: Georgia
Arkansas (entered the SEC together)
Vanderbilt (both from SEC east)
Tennessee: Alabama
Vanderbilt
Florida (both from SEC east)
Texas A&M: LSU
Miss State (geographic proximity)
Missouri (entered the SEC together)
Vanderbilt: Tennessee
Kentucky (border state)
South Carolina (both from SEC east)
Note: when picking three teams for each school, not all rivalries could be preserved. For example, LSU/Auburn and Tennessee/Kentucky. But in this system, these rivalries still will be played two out of every four years.
Next, seven of the 14 teams will be assigned to play two home games and one away game versus their permanent opponents in years one and three. The other seven will play two away games and one home game in years one and three. In years two and four they will switch.
The next step was to pick the first five teams of the remaining ten that each team would play in season one and two. And then the remaining five teams each team would face in season three and four. To make sure each team would play a balance schedule (a mix of traditionally strong and weak teams each year) each team was ranked 1 through 14 based on their historic conference and/or overall winning percentage. (Note: The rankings are not based solely on conference winning percentage because of the addition of four teams in recent history. That created too small of a sample size.) The rank is as follows
1. Alabama
2. Tennessee
3. Georgia
4. Florida
5. LSU
6. Auburn
7. Texas A&M
8. Arkansas
9. Ole Miss
10. Missouri
11. South Carolina
12. Miss State
13. Kentucky
14. Vanderbilt
Each team was in assigned five rotating opponents for years one and two, trying to maintain a balanced schedule. For example, in year one Alabama will play:
Home 6. Auburn (p)
7. Texas A&M
10. Missouri
11. South Carolina
Away 2. Tennessee (p)
5. LSU
9. Ole Miss (p)
14. Vanderbilt
In year two, they will play the same teams as in year one, but switch home/away.
In year three Alabama will play:
Home 3. Georgia
4. Florida
5. Auburn (p)
12. Miss State
Away 2. Tennessee (p)
8. Arkansas
9. Ole Miss (p)
13. Kentucky
In year four, they will play the same teams as in year three, but switch home/away.
The attached excel sheet (below) will have each teams schedule. (Year 2018 is designated as year one in the spreadsheet)
The Result: 1. A more balanced and fair schedule over time.
2. The championship game will host the two best teams.
3. Each four year player will play every school twice and visit every stadium in the SEC.
Click for Full Image (new window)